Borrowing Above the Cap Rate: When Debt Still Makes Sense

Apartment mortgages cost more than recent cap rates. Why most real estate is still bought with debt, how much growth borrowing needs to pay off, and when it backfires.

Recent Philadelphia-area apartment sales have priced at cap rates in the mid-5% range, while apartment mortgages in 2026 have cost roughly 6% to 7%. At first glance, borrowing at 6.75% to buy a property that yields 5.5% looks like losing money on every borrowed dollar. Yet most real estate is still bought with debt. This article explains why that can make sense, and when it doesn't.

Important: This article is general education. Every figure in it is a hypothetical illustration built on stated assumptions. None of it describes, projects or predicts the returns of any actual or proposed investment, including any offering by the author.

Two Different Measures

  • The cap rate is a property's net operating income (rent minus operating costs, before any loan payments) divided by its value. A $5 million property earning $275,000 a year has a 5.5% cap rate. It measures income only.

  • The interest rate is what the lender charges each year on the loan balance.

Comparing the two tells you whether the property's income covers the cost of the debt. It leaves out the other half of what an owner earns: the change in the property's value.

Income Versus Total Return

Take a hypothetical $5 million apartment property with a 5.5% cap rate. One buyer pays cash. Another borrows $2.83 million at 6.75% interest-only and puts down $2.17 million.

Year one

All cash

With debt

Equity invested

$5,000,000

$2,170,000

Net operating income

$275,000

$275,000

Interest

$0

$191,000

Cash flow

$275,000

$84,000

Cash yield on equity

5.5%

3.9%

Hypothetical illustration. Not a projection of returns.

On income alone, debt hurts: the borrower's cash yield drops from 5.5% to 3.9%. This is what people mean by negative leverage.

But owners also earn the change in value. If the property's value rises 3% a year, the all-cash owner's total return is roughly 5.5% income plus 3% growth, or 8.5%. That is above the 6.75% cost of debt. On a total return basis, each borrowed dollar earns about 8.5% and costs 6.75%, and the owner keeps the difference.

The Breakeven: How Much Growth Debt Needs

Debt adds to returns when the property's total return (cap rate plus value growth) is higher than the interest rate. With a 5.5% cap rate and 6.75% interest, the property needs about 1.25% a year of value growth just to break even on the debt.

A simple way to see it: the return on equity equals the property's total return, plus the spread over the interest rate earned on every borrowed dollar.

Annual value growth

Property's total return (all cash)

Return on equity with debt

0%

5.5%

3.9%

1%

6.5%

6.2%

1.25%

6.75%

6.75%

2%

7.5%

8.5%

3%

8.5%

10.8%

4%

9.5%

13.1%

Hypothetical illustration, before fees, transaction costs and taxes, assuming the cap rate stays the same and the loan covers 56.6% of value ($1.30 of debt per $1 of equity). Not a projection of returns.

Below the breakeven, debt makes things worse. Above it, debt magnifies the gain, and the gap widens quickly. A value-add plan that raises the property's income can lower the growth needed from the market.

Over 30 Years: With and Without Debt

The same idea holds over a long hold. The table compares two hypothetical owners who each start with $2.65 million and never sell. One borrows to buy a $5 million property; the other pays cash for a $2.42 million property. Both complete the same renovation plan, pay the same fees and taxes, and keep the cash flow.

Equity plus cash received by year 30

With debt

All cash

3% annual growth

$16.4 million

$10.6 million

1% annual growth

$8.4 million

$6.9 million

0% growth

$5.2 million

$5.6 million

Hypothetical illustration based on the assumptions in the appendix. Not a projection of returns.

With steady growth, the owner using debt finishes well ahead. With no growth, the all-cash owner wins. Near 1% growth the outcome is close, and in the same model an owner who sells and buys every six years, paying fees and tax each time, came out behind without debt even at 1% growth.

Why Owners Still Borrow

  • Appreciation is earned on the whole property. The borrower earns value growth on $5 million of property with $2.17 million of equity.

  • A fixed payment gets easier over time. With a fixed-rate loan, rents can rise while the interest payment stays the same, so the cash yield improves each year. In the example, at 3% rent growth, cash flow after interest roughly doubles in about nine years.

  • Inflation shrinks the debt. A fixed loan is repaid in future dollars that are worth less, which shifts value from the lender to the owner.

  • Interest is tax-deductible. Interest reduces taxable rental income, and the borrower also depreciates a larger property. In the 30-year example, the all-cash owner paid far more tax on rental income.

  • Rates may fall. An owner who expects lower rates later may accept negative leverage today and refinance if rates decline, though that is not guaranteed.

  • Capital goes further. Debt lets investors spread the same capital across more or larger properties.

When It Backfires

Borrowing above the cap rate is a bet that growth will beat the interest rate. It goes wrong when:

  • Growth falls short. Below about 1.25% a year in this example, debt lowers returns. If values fall, the loss on equity is magnified.

  • Rates rise at refinancing. A loan that matures when rates are higher can cut cash flow or force a sale at a bad time.

  • The rate floats. Floating-rate debt rises with market rates, which can wipe out the spread. Interest rate caps help but expire.

  • Cash flow gets tight. A thin margin between income and interest leaves little room for vacancy, repairs or rising insurance and taxes. If income falls below the loan payment, investors may have to add capital.

  • The lender takes control. Missing payments or breaking loan terms can lead to foreclosure, which can wipe out the equity entirely.

  • More debt is added on top. Refinancing to buy more property magnifies all of these risks. In the same 30-year model, at 1% growth, an owner who refinanced to buy more property finished behind one who kept a single loan.

Questions LPs Should Ask

  • What growth does the plan need? Ask what annual value or rent growth the deal requires for debt to help, and how that compares with the market's history.

  • What is the cash yield in year one, and when does it improve? A low starting yield may be acceptable if the plan shows how it grows.

  • Is the debt fixed or floating, and when does it mature?

  • How much cushion is there? Ask how far income could fall before it no longer covers the loan payment.

  • What happens in a downturn? Ask whether investors could be asked for more capital.

The Bottom Line

An interest rate above the cap rate does not automatically make debt a bad idea. The cap rate measures only income; total return also includes the change in value. In this hypothetical example, debt helped when values grew more than about 1.25% a year and hurt when they didn't. Borrowing at negative leverage is a bet on growth, so the questions that matter are how much growth the plan needs and what protects investors if it doesn't come.

Appendix: Assumptions

The figures in this article are a hypothetical illustration. They are not projected, targeted or expected returns for any investment, and actual results could be materially worse, including loss of principal.

Assumption

Value used

Property

$5,000,000 apartment property (with debt) or $2,420,000 (all cash)

Cap rate

5.5% of value, held constant

Loan

56.6% of value, interest-only at 6.75%; sized as the lower of 60% loan-to-value or 1.25× coverage of a 30-year amortizing payment

Return on equity with debt (breakeven table)

Total return + (total return − 6.75%) × $1.30 of debt per $1 of equity; before fees, costs and taxes

30-year comparison

$2,647,000 starting capital per owner; 4.5% purchase costs; 5% renovation budget creating 10% of purchase price in value over two years; 1% annual asset management fee on equity; rental income taxed at 43.87% (federal, net investment income tax and Pennsylvania) after interest and depreciation; 80% of cost depreciated over 27.5 years; cash flow distributed, not reinvested; no sale; no time value of money

Sources

This article is for educational purposes only and is not an offer to sell, or a solicitation of an offer to buy, any security. Any offering would be made only to eligible investors through formal offering documents. No money or other consideration is being solicited, and if sent, it will not be accepted. Any indication of interest involves no obligation or commitment of any kind.

The examples are hypothetical. They do not represent any actual or proposed investment and are not a projection or guarantee of future results. Real estate investments involve risk, including loss of principal. Tax outcomes depend on individual circumstances and on current law, which can change. Figures reflect market data as of October 2026. Consult a qualified tax advisor and securities counsel before making any decision.

Recent Philadelphia-area apartment sales have priced at cap rates in the mid-5% range, while apartment mortgages in 2026 have cost roughly 6% to 7%. At first glance, borrowing at 6.75% to buy a property that yields 5.5% looks like losing money on every borrowed dollar. Yet most real estate is still bought with debt. This article explains why that can make sense, and when it doesn't.

Important: This article is general education. Every figure in it is a hypothetical illustration built on stated assumptions. None of it describes, projects or predicts the returns of any actual or proposed investment, including any offering by the author.

Two Different Measures

  • The cap rate is a property's net operating income (rent minus operating costs, before any loan payments) divided by its value. A $5 million property earning $275,000 a year has a 5.5% cap rate. It measures income only.

  • The interest rate is what the lender charges each year on the loan balance.

Comparing the two tells you whether the property's income covers the cost of the debt. It leaves out the other half of what an owner earns: the change in the property's value.

Income Versus Total Return

Take a hypothetical $5 million apartment property with a 5.5% cap rate. One buyer pays cash. Another borrows $2.83 million at 6.75% interest-only and puts down $2.17 million.

Year one

All cash

With debt

Equity invested

$5,000,000

$2,170,000

Net operating income

$275,000

$275,000

Interest

$0

$191,000

Cash flow

$275,000

$84,000

Cash yield on equity

5.5%

3.9%

Hypothetical illustration. Not a projection of returns.

On income alone, debt hurts: the borrower's cash yield drops from 5.5% to 3.9%. This is what people mean by negative leverage.

But owners also earn the change in value. If the property's value rises 3% a year, the all-cash owner's total return is roughly 5.5% income plus 3% growth, or 8.5%. That is above the 6.75% cost of debt. On a total return basis, each borrowed dollar earns about 8.5% and costs 6.75%, and the owner keeps the difference.

The Breakeven: How Much Growth Debt Needs

Debt adds to returns when the property's total return (cap rate plus value growth) is higher than the interest rate. With a 5.5% cap rate and 6.75% interest, the property needs about 1.25% a year of value growth just to break even on the debt.

A simple way to see it: the return on equity equals the property's total return, plus the spread over the interest rate earned on every borrowed dollar.

Annual value growth

Property's total return (all cash)

Return on equity with debt

0%

5.5%

3.9%

1%

6.5%

6.2%

1.25%

6.75%

6.75%

2%

7.5%

8.5%

3%

8.5%

10.8%

4%

9.5%

13.1%

Hypothetical illustration, before fees, transaction costs and taxes, assuming the cap rate stays the same and the loan covers 56.6% of value ($1.30 of debt per $1 of equity). Not a projection of returns.

Below the breakeven, debt makes things worse. Above it, debt magnifies the gain, and the gap widens quickly. A value-add plan that raises the property's income can lower the growth needed from the market.

Over 30 Years: With and Without Debt

The same idea holds over a long hold. The table compares two hypothetical owners who each start with $2.65 million and never sell. One borrows to buy a $5 million property; the other pays cash for a $2.42 million property. Both complete the same renovation plan, pay the same fees and taxes, and keep the cash flow.

Equity plus cash received by year 30

With debt

All cash

3% annual growth

$16.4 million

$10.6 million

1% annual growth

$8.4 million

$6.9 million

0% growth

$5.2 million

$5.6 million

Hypothetical illustration based on the assumptions in the appendix. Not a projection of returns.

With steady growth, the owner using debt finishes well ahead. With no growth, the all-cash owner wins. Near 1% growth the outcome is close, and in the same model an owner who sells and buys every six years, paying fees and tax each time, came out behind without debt even at 1% growth.

Why Owners Still Borrow

  • Appreciation is earned on the whole property. The borrower earns value growth on $5 million of property with $2.17 million of equity.

  • A fixed payment gets easier over time. With a fixed-rate loan, rents can rise while the interest payment stays the same, so the cash yield improves each year. In the example, at 3% rent growth, cash flow after interest roughly doubles in about nine years.

  • Inflation shrinks the debt. A fixed loan is repaid in future dollars that are worth less, which shifts value from the lender to the owner.

  • Interest is tax-deductible. Interest reduces taxable rental income, and the borrower also depreciates a larger property. In the 30-year example, the all-cash owner paid far more tax on rental income.

  • Rates may fall. An owner who expects lower rates later may accept negative leverage today and refinance if rates decline, though that is not guaranteed.

  • Capital goes further. Debt lets investors spread the same capital across more or larger properties.

When It Backfires

Borrowing above the cap rate is a bet that growth will beat the interest rate. It goes wrong when:

  • Growth falls short. Below about 1.25% a year in this example, debt lowers returns. If values fall, the loss on equity is magnified.

  • Rates rise at refinancing. A loan that matures when rates are higher can cut cash flow or force a sale at a bad time.

  • The rate floats. Floating-rate debt rises with market rates, which can wipe out the spread. Interest rate caps help but expire.

  • Cash flow gets tight. A thin margin between income and interest leaves little room for vacancy, repairs or rising insurance and taxes. If income falls below the loan payment, investors may have to add capital.

  • The lender takes control. Missing payments or breaking loan terms can lead to foreclosure, which can wipe out the equity entirely.

  • More debt is added on top. Refinancing to buy more property magnifies all of these risks. In the same 30-year model, at 1% growth, an owner who refinanced to buy more property finished behind one who kept a single loan.

Questions LPs Should Ask

  • What growth does the plan need? Ask what annual value or rent growth the deal requires for debt to help, and how that compares with the market's history.

  • What is the cash yield in year one, and when does it improve? A low starting yield may be acceptable if the plan shows how it grows.

  • Is the debt fixed or floating, and when does it mature?

  • How much cushion is there? Ask how far income could fall before it no longer covers the loan payment.

  • What happens in a downturn? Ask whether investors could be asked for more capital.

The Bottom Line

An interest rate above the cap rate does not automatically make debt a bad idea. The cap rate measures only income; total return also includes the change in value. In this hypothetical example, debt helped when values grew more than about 1.25% a year and hurt when they didn't. Borrowing at negative leverage is a bet on growth, so the questions that matter are how much growth the plan needs and what protects investors if it doesn't come.

Appendix: Assumptions

The figures in this article are a hypothetical illustration. They are not projected, targeted or expected returns for any investment, and actual results could be materially worse, including loss of principal.

Assumption

Value used

Property

$5,000,000 apartment property (with debt) or $2,420,000 (all cash)

Cap rate

5.5% of value, held constant

Loan

56.6% of value, interest-only at 6.75%; sized as the lower of 60% loan-to-value or 1.25× coverage of a 30-year amortizing payment

Return on equity with debt (breakeven table)

Total return + (total return − 6.75%) × $1.30 of debt per $1 of equity; before fees, costs and taxes

30-year comparison

$2,647,000 starting capital per owner; 4.5% purchase costs; 5% renovation budget creating 10% of purchase price in value over two years; 1% annual asset management fee on equity; rental income taxed at 43.87% (federal, net investment income tax and Pennsylvania) after interest and depreciation; 80% of cost depreciated over 27.5 years; cash flow distributed, not reinvested; no sale; no time value of money

Sources

This article is for educational purposes only and is not an offer to sell, or a solicitation of an offer to buy, any security. Any offering would be made only to eligible investors through formal offering documents. No money or other consideration is being solicited, and if sent, it will not be accepted. Any indication of interest involves no obligation or commitment of any kind.

The examples are hypothetical. They do not represent any actual or proposed investment and are not a projection or guarantee of future results. Real estate investments involve risk, including loss of principal. Tax outcomes depend on individual circumstances and on current law, which can change. Figures reflect market data as of October 2026. Consult a qualified tax advisor and securities counsel before making any decision.

General information only. Not investment, legal or tax advice.

Interest list

Interested in future opportunities?

Join the interest list to hear if we launch an offering.

McEvoy Capital logo

McEvoy Capital is considering an offering of securities exempt from registration under the Securities Act of 1933, but has not determined the specific exemption from registration it intends to rely on for the subsequent offer and sale of the securities. No money or other consideration is being solicited, and if sent in response, will not be accepted. No offer to buy the securities can be accepted and no part of the purchase price can be received until McEvoy Capital determines the exemption under which the offering is intended to be conducted and, where applicable, the filing, disclosure, or qualification requirements of such exemption are met. A person’s indication of interest involves no obligation or commitment of any kind.

McEvoy Capital is not offering securities on this website. Nothing here is an offer to sell, or a solicitation of an offer to buy, any security. Any offering will be made only through official offering documents and only to eligible investors. Real estate investing involves risk, including loss of principal.

© 2026 McEvoy Capital · Privacy Policy · Terms of Use