The Cost of Selling: What a Long Hold Means for Syndication Investors
Most syndications sell after five to seven years. A hypothetical 30-year example of what that cycle costs limited partners, and how a long hold changes the picture.
Most real estate syndications sell their property after five to seven years. Investors get their money back, pay tax on the gain, and look for the next deal, paying a new round of fees when they find it. This article walks through a simple example of what that cycle costs over 30 years, and how holding a property long term changes the picture.
Important: This article is general education about costs and tax rules. Every figure in it is a hypothetical illustration built on stated assumptions. None of it describes, projects or predicts the returns of any actual or proposed investment, including any offering by the author. The full calculations and assumptions are in the appendices.
What Happens When a Syndication Sells
For a limited partner (LP), a sale usually means three things:
Cash back, after costs. The loan is repaid, closing costs and the sponsor’s disposition fee are paid, and the rest is distributed.
A tax bill. Your K-1 reports your share of the gain. Part of it is depreciation recapture, taxed at up to 25%, which is often larger than investors expect because the depreciation deducted over the years lowered your basis.
A new deal to find. Reinvesting means paying a new acquisition fee, new closing costs and new transfer tax, and your cash may sit idle while you look.
Can’t I Just Do a 1031 Exchange?
Usually not on your own. Since 2018, 1031 exchanges apply only to real property, and an LP interest in an LLC or partnership is not real property. You can’t exchange your share of one syndication into another.
The partnership itself can do an exchange: it sells the property and buys a replacement, and every investor’s tax is deferred. But all investors must roll together, the operating agreement has to allow it, and the sponsor has to choose to do it. Investors who want cash at the sale make this hard, and the workarounds draw IRS scrutiny. Delaware Statutory Trusts (DSTs) and tenant-in-common (TIC) interests are the exception, because they count as real property.
In a typical sell-and-distribute syndication, then, an LP is the "Seller" in the example below, not the "Exchanger."
The Example
Three owners each start with the same hypothetical $5 million Bucks County property, purchased with $2 million of equity and a $3 million loan:
The Seller sells every six years, pays the tax and reinvests. This is what most syndication LPs experience.
The Exchanger does the same, but the partnership uses a 1031 exchange to defer the tax.
The Holder still owns at the end.
What One Sale Costs
One sell-and-reinvest cycle on the $5 million property costs $425,000:
Cost | Rate | Amount |
|---|---|---|
Sponsor disposition fee | 1.5% of sale price | $75,000 |
Seller’s share of PA realty transfer tax | 1% | $50,000 |
Brokerage and legal (sale) | 1.5% | $75,000 |
Sponsor acquisition fee, next deal | 2% of purchase price | $100,000 |
Buyer’s share of PA realty transfer tax | 1% | $50,000 |
Closing and financing costs (purchase) | 1.5% | $75,000 |
Total | 8.5% of value | $425,000 |
That is about 21% of the $2 million of equity in the property, before any income tax. Fee levels vary by sponsor; these rates sit within commonly cited market ranges. Pennsylvania’s realty transfer tax is 2% in most of Bucks County, usually split between buyer and seller.
What It Adds Up to Over 30 Years
The Seller and Exchanger each repeat that cycle four times. With property values assumed to rise 3% a year, the costs grow with them:
Paid over 30 years | Seller | Exchanger | Holder |
|---|---|---|---|
Fees, transfer taxes and closing costs | $2,926,000 | $2,926,000 | $225,000 |
Income tax on sales | $2,271,000 | $0 | $0 |
Total | $5,197,000 | $2,926,000 | $225,000 |
Hypothetical illustration based on the assumptions in Appendix A. Not a projection of returns.
In this example all three end up owning a property of the same value, so the difference is only what each paid along the way. A 1031 exchange defers the tax, but it doesn’t reduce the fees. Appendix A shows each cycle.
Untaxed Gains at Year 30
Fees are only part of the difference. Each owner also ends year 30 with gain that has not yet been taxed: the property’s value less its remaining tax basis, including depreciation that hasn’t been recaptured.
In this hypothetical example, the Holder has about $11.1 million of untaxed gain at year 30, carrying about $3.2 million of income tax it has not paid. The Exchanger has $8.4 million of untaxed gain and about $2.3 million of tax not yet paid. The Seller has only $3.4 million and about $1.0 million, because it already paid tax at every sale.
Untaxed gain is deferred, not forgiven: tax would be due if the property were sold. Until then, the money that would have gone to tax stays invested in the property.
What If Each New Deal Adds Value?
Sponsors that sell often argue that each new property brings a fresh value-add, such as renovations or re-leasing. Appendix B tests this with a fuller hypothetical model: rental income, loan payments at current rates, the same asset management fee for everyone, no outside cash, and every renovation succeeding as planned. It also adds a fourth owner, a Holder that refinances every six years and buys another property with the cash, without ever selling.
By year 30 | Seller | Exchanger | Holder | Holder that refinances |
|---|---|---|---|---|
Value-add projects completed | 5 | 5 | 1 | 5 |
Fees, transaction and financing costs | $3,280,000 | $4,471,000 | $225,000 | $1,528,000 |
Income tax on sales | $2,759,000 | $0 | $0 | $0 |
Debt as a share of property value | 36% | 36% | 0% | 39% |
Equity plus cash flow received | $11,814,000 | $19,016,000 | $17,986,000 | $26,282,000 |
Hypothetical illustration only. These figures come from a simplified model using the assumptions in Appendix B. They are not projected, targeted or expected returns for any investment, and actual results could be materially worse, including loss of principal.
Even with every project succeeding, the Seller, the typical LP’s path, finishes last. The Holder that refinances finishes ahead of the Exchanger at similar debt levels. For the Exchanger to catch it, each of its five projects would need to add about 15.0% of the purchase price in value; the Seller would need about 24.6%.
Every new value-add also brings risks that the model assumes away: renovation overruns, slow lease-up, selling into a weak market, higher interest rates on the next loan, and missed 1031 deadlines (45 days to identify a replacement, 180 to close).
What a Long Hold Asks of Investors
Holding long term trades transaction costs for other commitments:
Less liquidity. There is no planned exit. Investors depend on distributions from cash flow (not guaranteed), cash-out refinancings (generally not taxable, but they add debt) or a sponsor buyback of their interest, if offered, on terms that aren’t assured. Selling your interest early triggers tax on your share of the gain.
More trust in the sponsor. The sponsor decides when to refinance, how much to borrow and what price to pay in a buyback, which can create conflicts of interest. Ongoing asset management fees run for as long as the hold lasts, so compare them with the transaction fees saved.
Property risk for longer. Values can fall, buildings age and need major capital spending, interest rates change, and a long hold ties capital to the same properties and location for decades.
The Bottom Line
For a typical LP, every sale pays a disposition fee, a new acquisition fee, transfer taxes and income tax, and restarts the clock. In this hypothetical example, those costs totaled $5.2 million over 30 years for the owner who sold every six years, compared with $225,000 for the owner who held. Whether a long hold suits you depends on how much liquidity you need and how much you trust the sponsor to manage the property for decades.
Appendix A: The Base Example in Detail
The figures in this appendix are a hypothetical illustration of costs and tax rules. They are not a projection of returns for any investment.
To isolate costs and taxes, every replacement property is bought for the same price the old one sold for, and costs and taxes are paid from outside the property. Property values rise 3% a year, for illustration only, so all three owners hold a property of the same value at every point.
Cost of Each Sale
Year of sale | Property value | Transaction costs (8.5%) | Seller’s income tax due |
|---|---|---|---|
6 | $5,970,000 | $507,000 | $427,000 |
12 | $7,129,000 | $606,000 | $510,000 |
18 | $8,512,000 | $724,000 | $608,000 |
24 | $10,164,000 | $864,000 | $726,000 |
Total | $2,701,000 | $2,271,000 |
The Seller’s tax at each sale includes depreciation recapture at up to 25%.
Position at Year 30
Seller | Exchanger | Holder | |
|---|---|---|---|
Original purchase costs (4.5%) | $225,000 | $225,000 | $225,000 |
Transaction costs on later sales | $2,701,000 | $2,701,000 | $0 |
Income tax paid on sales | $2,271,000 | $0 | $0 |
Total costs and taxes paid | $5,197,000 | $2,926,000 | $225,000 |
Property value at year 30 | $12,136,000 | $12,136,000 | $12,136,000 |
Untaxed gain at year 30 | $3,369,000 | $8,351,000 | $11,091,000 |
Income tax not yet paid on that gain | $998,000 | $2,284,000 | $3,189,000 |
The Holder’s untaxed gain includes $4.2 million of depreciation deducted over the years, which has not been recaptured or taxed by year 30.
Assumptions: 80% of property value depreciable over 27.5 years; 25% depreciation recapture and 20% long-term capital gains rates, plus 3.8% net investment income tax and 3.07% Pennsylvania income tax; a $3 million loan. Purchase costs are added to tax basis. Rental income, loan payments, operating costs and ongoing sponsor fees are excluded because they would be the same for all three owners. Amounts paid in different years are added without adjusting for the time value of money.
Appendix B: The Value-Add Model
The figures in this appendix come from a simplified hypothetical model. They are not projected, targeted or expected returns for any investment, and actual results could be materially worse, including loss of principal.
This model adds rental income, interest and ongoing fees, and removes outside cash: each owner starts with the same capital, and everything it later pays in fees, renovations and taxes reduces what it can put into its next purchase.
Model Assumptions
Assumption | Value used |
|---|---|
Starting capital | $2,822,000 per owner: $2,347,000 down payment, $225,000 purchase costs and $250,000 renovation budget on a $5,000,000 property with a $2,653,000 loan |
Rental income | Net operating income of 5.5% of property value each year, in line with mid-5% cap rates on recent Philadelphia-area apartment sales |
Interest rate | 6.75% on every loan, within the 2026 range for apartment mortgages, repaid with monthly payments over 25 years |
Loan size | The lower of 60% of value or the amount that keeps net operating income at 1.25× the annual loan payment; at these rates, 53.1% of value |
Asset management fee | 1% of each owner’s equity per year, paid from cash flow |
Cash flow | Net operating income less loan payments (interest and principal), asset management fee and income tax; distributed, not reinvested |
Tax on rental income | 37% federal, 3.8% net investment income tax and 3.07% Pennsylvania, after interest, fees and depreciation; losses carried forward |
Sale costs | 4% of sale price, plus 2% of the loan balance as a prepayment cost |
Purchase costs | 4.5% of purchase price |
Refinance costs | 1% of the new loan, plus 2% of the old loan balance as a prepayment cost |
Capital for the next purchase | Sale price less sale costs, loan payoff and, for the Seller, income tax on the sale |
Size of the next purchase | Capital available ÷ 56.4% (46.9% down payment + 4.5% purchase costs + 5% renovation budget) |
Renovation budget | 5% of each property’s purchase price, paid at purchase |
Value created | 10% of purchase price over the first two years (5% each year), on top of 3% annual market growth; rental income rises with value |
Success rate | Every project finishes on budget and on schedule |
Holder | One project; the original loan is paid off in year 25 |
Holder that refinances | Every six years, refinances each property up to the loan-size limit and buys another property with the cash, with the same value-add plan |
Depreciation | Straight-line over 27.5 years on 80% of cost, including renovations; no cost segregation or bonus depreciation, which would favor owners who buy more often |
Not modeled | Lost rent during renovation, lease-up time, cash sitting idle between deals, capital spending as buildings age, and changes in cap rates or interest rates |
At a 5.5% cap rate and 6.75% interest, each borrowed dollar costs more than the property earns on it, so debt adds value only through appreciation and the value-add.
Why a 10% Value-Add
A renovation budget of 5% of the purchase price that creates 10% of the price in value works out to about an 11% annual return on the renovation cost at a 5.5% cap rate. Sponsors interviewed in industry reporting underwrite renovations to returns of 20% or more on cost and cite completed projects that achieved roughly 12% to 17%, while one large apartment owner sets 10% as its minimum. A 10% value-add is therefore a moderate assumption: below typical targets, near the low end of achieved results. The sensitivity table at the end of this appendix shows results from 5% to 15%.
How Fees and Taxes Shrink Each Reinvestment
Every $1 lost to fees or tax at a sale reduces the next purchase price by about $1.77.
Year of sale | Seller’s income tax on sale | Seller: capital to reinvest | Seller: next purchase price | Exchanger: capital to reinvest | Exchanger: next purchase price |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
6 | $521,000 | $3,360,000 | $5,954,000 | $3,881,000 | $6,877,000 |
12 | $620,000 | $4,001,000 | $7,090,000 | $5,337,000 | $9,459,000 |
18 | $739,000 | $4,764,000 | $8,443,000 | $7,341,000 | $13,009,000 |
24 | $879,000 | $5,674,000 | $10,054,000 | $10,097,000 | $17,893,000 |
How the Refinancing Holder Adds Properties
Year of refinance | Cash after refinance and prepayment costs | Next purchase price |
|---|---|---|
6 | $1,038,000 | $1,839,000 |
12 | $1,347,000 | $2,386,000 |
18 | $2,003,000 | $3,549,000 |
24 | $2,997,000 | $5,311,000 |
Full Comparison at Year 30
Seller | Exchanger | Holder | Holder that refinances | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
Value-add projects completed | 5 | 5 | 1 | 5 |
Properties owned at year 30 | 1 | 1 | 1 | 5 |
Fees, transfer taxes, closing, prepayment and refinance costs | $3,280,000 | $4,471,000 | $225,000 | $1,528,000 |
Renovation budgets | $1,827,000 | $2,612,000 | $250,000 | $904,000 |
Asset management fees | $1,537,000 | $2,197,000 | $2,248,000 | $2,751,000 |
Interest paid | $7,444,000 | $10,642,000 | $2,847,000 | $14,892,000 |
Income tax on sales | $2,759,000 | $0 | $0 | $0 |
Income tax on rental income | $0 | $822,000 | $2,315,000 | $90,000 |
Property value at year 30 | $13,154,000 | $23,409,000 | $13,297,000 | $34,336,000 |
Loan balance at year 30 | $4,730,000 | $8,417,000 | $0 | $13,288,000 |
Equity at year 30 | $8,424,000 | $14,992,000 | $13,297,000 | $21,048,000 |
After-tax cash flow received over 30 years | $3,390,000 | $4,024,000 | $4,688,000 | $5,234,000 |
Equity plus cash flow received | $11,814,000 | $19,016,000 | $17,986,000 | $26,282,000 |
Untaxed gain at year 30 | $4,066,000 | $15,466,000 | $12,202,000 | $24,059,000 |
Income tax not yet paid on that gain | $1,189,000 | $4,240,000 | $3,498,000 | $6,941,000 |
Hypothetical illustration. Not a projection of returns.
Owners who sell get fresh depreciation with each purchase and pay little tax on rental income. The Holder that never refinances pays $2.3 million as its depreciation runs out. The refinancing Holder ends with the most untaxed gain, $24.1 million, because it never sold.
Sensitivity to Value Created
Value created per project | Seller | Exchanger | Holder that refinances |
|---|---|---|---|
5% of price | $8,662,000 | $13,553,000 | $23,132,000 |
7.5% | $10,143,000 | $16,091,000 | $24,703,000 |
10% | $11,814,000 | $19,016,000 | $26,282,000 |
12.5% | $13,693,000 | $22,371,000 | $27,947,000 |
15% | $15,798,000 | $26,203,000 | $29,714,000 |
Hypothetical equity plus after-tax cash flow received by year 30; every owner’s projects use the same rate. Not a projection of returns.
With the refinancing Holder’s projects at 10%, the Exchanger’s would each need to create about 15.0% of purchase price to match it, and the Seller’s about 24.6%.
Sources
This article is for educational purposes only and is not an offer to sell, or a solicitation of an offer to buy, any security. Any offering would be made only to eligible investors through formal offering documents. No money or other consideration is being solicited, and if sent, it will not be accepted. Any indication of interest involves no obligation or commitment of any kind.
The example is hypothetical. It does not represent any actual or proposed investment and is not a projection or guarantee of future results. Real estate investments involve risk, including loss of principal. Tax outcomes depend on individual circumstances and on current law, which can change. Figures reflect federal and Pennsylvania law as of October 2026. Consult a qualified tax advisor, estate attorney and securities counsel before making any decision.
Most real estate syndications sell their property after five to seven years. Investors get their money back, pay tax on the gain, and look for the next deal, paying a new round of fees when they find it. This article walks through a simple example of what that cycle costs over 30 years, and how holding a property long term changes the picture.
Important: This article is general education about costs and tax rules. Every figure in it is a hypothetical illustration built on stated assumptions. None of it describes, projects or predicts the returns of any actual or proposed investment, including any offering by the author. The full calculations and assumptions are in the appendices.
What Happens When a Syndication Sells
For a limited partner (LP), a sale usually means three things:
Cash back, after costs. The loan is repaid, closing costs and the sponsor’s disposition fee are paid, and the rest is distributed.
A tax bill. Your K-1 reports your share of the gain. Part of it is depreciation recapture, taxed at up to 25%, which is often larger than investors expect because the depreciation deducted over the years lowered your basis.
A new deal to find. Reinvesting means paying a new acquisition fee, new closing costs and new transfer tax, and your cash may sit idle while you look.
Can’t I Just Do a 1031 Exchange?
Usually not on your own. Since 2018, 1031 exchanges apply only to real property, and an LP interest in an LLC or partnership is not real property. You can’t exchange your share of one syndication into another.
The partnership itself can do an exchange: it sells the property and buys a replacement, and every investor’s tax is deferred. But all investors must roll together, the operating agreement has to allow it, and the sponsor has to choose to do it. Investors who want cash at the sale make this hard, and the workarounds draw IRS scrutiny. Delaware Statutory Trusts (DSTs) and tenant-in-common (TIC) interests are the exception, because they count as real property.
In a typical sell-and-distribute syndication, then, an LP is the "Seller" in the example below, not the "Exchanger."
The Example
Three owners each start with the same hypothetical $5 million Bucks County property, purchased with $2 million of equity and a $3 million loan:
The Seller sells every six years, pays the tax and reinvests. This is what most syndication LPs experience.
The Exchanger does the same, but the partnership uses a 1031 exchange to defer the tax.
The Holder still owns at the end.
What One Sale Costs
One sell-and-reinvest cycle on the $5 million property costs $425,000:
Cost | Rate | Amount |
|---|---|---|
Sponsor disposition fee | 1.5% of sale price | $75,000 |
Seller’s share of PA realty transfer tax | 1% | $50,000 |
Brokerage and legal (sale) | 1.5% | $75,000 |
Sponsor acquisition fee, next deal | 2% of purchase price | $100,000 |
Buyer’s share of PA realty transfer tax | 1% | $50,000 |
Closing and financing costs (purchase) | 1.5% | $75,000 |
Total | 8.5% of value | $425,000 |
That is about 21% of the $2 million of equity in the property, before any income tax. Fee levels vary by sponsor; these rates sit within commonly cited market ranges. Pennsylvania’s realty transfer tax is 2% in most of Bucks County, usually split between buyer and seller.
What It Adds Up to Over 30 Years
The Seller and Exchanger each repeat that cycle four times. With property values assumed to rise 3% a year, the costs grow with them:
Paid over 30 years | Seller | Exchanger | Holder |
|---|---|---|---|
Fees, transfer taxes and closing costs | $2,926,000 | $2,926,000 | $225,000 |
Income tax on sales | $2,271,000 | $0 | $0 |
Total | $5,197,000 | $2,926,000 | $225,000 |
Hypothetical illustration based on the assumptions in Appendix A. Not a projection of returns.
In this example all three end up owning a property of the same value, so the difference is only what each paid along the way. A 1031 exchange defers the tax, but it doesn’t reduce the fees. Appendix A shows each cycle.
Untaxed Gains at Year 30
Fees are only part of the difference. Each owner also ends year 30 with gain that has not yet been taxed: the property’s value less its remaining tax basis, including depreciation that hasn’t been recaptured.
In this hypothetical example, the Holder has about $11.1 million of untaxed gain at year 30, carrying about $3.2 million of income tax it has not paid. The Exchanger has $8.4 million of untaxed gain and about $2.3 million of tax not yet paid. The Seller has only $3.4 million and about $1.0 million, because it already paid tax at every sale.
Untaxed gain is deferred, not forgiven: tax would be due if the property were sold. Until then, the money that would have gone to tax stays invested in the property.
What If Each New Deal Adds Value?
Sponsors that sell often argue that each new property brings a fresh value-add, such as renovations or re-leasing. Appendix B tests this with a fuller hypothetical model: rental income, loan payments at current rates, the same asset management fee for everyone, no outside cash, and every renovation succeeding as planned. It also adds a fourth owner, a Holder that refinances every six years and buys another property with the cash, without ever selling.
By year 30 | Seller | Exchanger | Holder | Holder that refinances |
|---|---|---|---|---|
Value-add projects completed | 5 | 5 | 1 | 5 |
Fees, transaction and financing costs | $3,280,000 | $4,471,000 | $225,000 | $1,528,000 |
Income tax on sales | $2,759,000 | $0 | $0 | $0 |
Debt as a share of property value | 36% | 36% | 0% | 39% |
Equity plus cash flow received | $11,814,000 | $19,016,000 | $17,986,000 | $26,282,000 |
Hypothetical illustration only. These figures come from a simplified model using the assumptions in Appendix B. They are not projected, targeted or expected returns for any investment, and actual results could be materially worse, including loss of principal.
Even with every project succeeding, the Seller, the typical LP’s path, finishes last. The Holder that refinances finishes ahead of the Exchanger at similar debt levels. For the Exchanger to catch it, each of its five projects would need to add about 15.0% of the purchase price in value; the Seller would need about 24.6%.
Every new value-add also brings risks that the model assumes away: renovation overruns, slow lease-up, selling into a weak market, higher interest rates on the next loan, and missed 1031 deadlines (45 days to identify a replacement, 180 to close).
What a Long Hold Asks of Investors
Holding long term trades transaction costs for other commitments:
Less liquidity. There is no planned exit. Investors depend on distributions from cash flow (not guaranteed), cash-out refinancings (generally not taxable, but they add debt) or a sponsor buyback of their interest, if offered, on terms that aren’t assured. Selling your interest early triggers tax on your share of the gain.
More trust in the sponsor. The sponsor decides when to refinance, how much to borrow and what price to pay in a buyback, which can create conflicts of interest. Ongoing asset management fees run for as long as the hold lasts, so compare them with the transaction fees saved.
Property risk for longer. Values can fall, buildings age and need major capital spending, interest rates change, and a long hold ties capital to the same properties and location for decades.
The Bottom Line
For a typical LP, every sale pays a disposition fee, a new acquisition fee, transfer taxes and income tax, and restarts the clock. In this hypothetical example, those costs totaled $5.2 million over 30 years for the owner who sold every six years, compared with $225,000 for the owner who held. Whether a long hold suits you depends on how much liquidity you need and how much you trust the sponsor to manage the property for decades.
Appendix A: The Base Example in Detail
The figures in this appendix are a hypothetical illustration of costs and tax rules. They are not a projection of returns for any investment.
To isolate costs and taxes, every replacement property is bought for the same price the old one sold for, and costs and taxes are paid from outside the property. Property values rise 3% a year, for illustration only, so all three owners hold a property of the same value at every point.
Cost of Each Sale
Year of sale | Property value | Transaction costs (8.5%) | Seller’s income tax due |
|---|---|---|---|
6 | $5,970,000 | $507,000 | $427,000 |
12 | $7,129,000 | $606,000 | $510,000 |
18 | $8,512,000 | $724,000 | $608,000 |
24 | $10,164,000 | $864,000 | $726,000 |
Total | $2,701,000 | $2,271,000 |
The Seller’s tax at each sale includes depreciation recapture at up to 25%.
Position at Year 30
Seller | Exchanger | Holder | |
|---|---|---|---|
Original purchase costs (4.5%) | $225,000 | $225,000 | $225,000 |
Transaction costs on later sales | $2,701,000 | $2,701,000 | $0 |
Income tax paid on sales | $2,271,000 | $0 | $0 |
Total costs and taxes paid | $5,197,000 | $2,926,000 | $225,000 |
Property value at year 30 | $12,136,000 | $12,136,000 | $12,136,000 |
Untaxed gain at year 30 | $3,369,000 | $8,351,000 | $11,091,000 |
Income tax not yet paid on that gain | $998,000 | $2,284,000 | $3,189,000 |
The Holder’s untaxed gain includes $4.2 million of depreciation deducted over the years, which has not been recaptured or taxed by year 30.
Assumptions: 80% of property value depreciable over 27.5 years; 25% depreciation recapture and 20% long-term capital gains rates, plus 3.8% net investment income tax and 3.07% Pennsylvania income tax; a $3 million loan. Purchase costs are added to tax basis. Rental income, loan payments, operating costs and ongoing sponsor fees are excluded because they would be the same for all three owners. Amounts paid in different years are added without adjusting for the time value of money.
Appendix B: The Value-Add Model
The figures in this appendix come from a simplified hypothetical model. They are not projected, targeted or expected returns for any investment, and actual results could be materially worse, including loss of principal.
This model adds rental income, interest and ongoing fees, and removes outside cash: each owner starts with the same capital, and everything it later pays in fees, renovations and taxes reduces what it can put into its next purchase.
Model Assumptions
Assumption | Value used |
|---|---|
Starting capital | $2,822,000 per owner: $2,347,000 down payment, $225,000 purchase costs and $250,000 renovation budget on a $5,000,000 property with a $2,653,000 loan |
Rental income | Net operating income of 5.5% of property value each year, in line with mid-5% cap rates on recent Philadelphia-area apartment sales |
Interest rate | 6.75% on every loan, within the 2026 range for apartment mortgages, repaid with monthly payments over 25 years |
Loan size | The lower of 60% of value or the amount that keeps net operating income at 1.25× the annual loan payment; at these rates, 53.1% of value |
Asset management fee | 1% of each owner’s equity per year, paid from cash flow |
Cash flow | Net operating income less loan payments (interest and principal), asset management fee and income tax; distributed, not reinvested |
Tax on rental income | 37% federal, 3.8% net investment income tax and 3.07% Pennsylvania, after interest, fees and depreciation; losses carried forward |
Sale costs | 4% of sale price, plus 2% of the loan balance as a prepayment cost |
Purchase costs | 4.5% of purchase price |
Refinance costs | 1% of the new loan, plus 2% of the old loan balance as a prepayment cost |
Capital for the next purchase | Sale price less sale costs, loan payoff and, for the Seller, income tax on the sale |
Size of the next purchase | Capital available ÷ 56.4% (46.9% down payment + 4.5% purchase costs + 5% renovation budget) |
Renovation budget | 5% of each property’s purchase price, paid at purchase |
Value created | 10% of purchase price over the first two years (5% each year), on top of 3% annual market growth; rental income rises with value |
Success rate | Every project finishes on budget and on schedule |
Holder | One project; the original loan is paid off in year 25 |
Holder that refinances | Every six years, refinances each property up to the loan-size limit and buys another property with the cash, with the same value-add plan |
Depreciation | Straight-line over 27.5 years on 80% of cost, including renovations; no cost segregation or bonus depreciation, which would favor owners who buy more often |
Not modeled | Lost rent during renovation, lease-up time, cash sitting idle between deals, capital spending as buildings age, and changes in cap rates or interest rates |
At a 5.5% cap rate and 6.75% interest, each borrowed dollar costs more than the property earns on it, so debt adds value only through appreciation and the value-add.
Why a 10% Value-Add
A renovation budget of 5% of the purchase price that creates 10% of the price in value works out to about an 11% annual return on the renovation cost at a 5.5% cap rate. Sponsors interviewed in industry reporting underwrite renovations to returns of 20% or more on cost and cite completed projects that achieved roughly 12% to 17%, while one large apartment owner sets 10% as its minimum. A 10% value-add is therefore a moderate assumption: below typical targets, near the low end of achieved results. The sensitivity table at the end of this appendix shows results from 5% to 15%.
How Fees and Taxes Shrink Each Reinvestment
Every $1 lost to fees or tax at a sale reduces the next purchase price by about $1.77.
Year of sale | Seller’s income tax on sale | Seller: capital to reinvest | Seller: next purchase price | Exchanger: capital to reinvest | Exchanger: next purchase price |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
6 | $521,000 | $3,360,000 | $5,954,000 | $3,881,000 | $6,877,000 |
12 | $620,000 | $4,001,000 | $7,090,000 | $5,337,000 | $9,459,000 |
18 | $739,000 | $4,764,000 | $8,443,000 | $7,341,000 | $13,009,000 |
24 | $879,000 | $5,674,000 | $10,054,000 | $10,097,000 | $17,893,000 |
How the Refinancing Holder Adds Properties
Year of refinance | Cash after refinance and prepayment costs | Next purchase price |
|---|---|---|
6 | $1,038,000 | $1,839,000 |
12 | $1,347,000 | $2,386,000 |
18 | $2,003,000 | $3,549,000 |
24 | $2,997,000 | $5,311,000 |
Full Comparison at Year 30
Seller | Exchanger | Holder | Holder that refinances | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
Value-add projects completed | 5 | 5 | 1 | 5 |
Properties owned at year 30 | 1 | 1 | 1 | 5 |
Fees, transfer taxes, closing, prepayment and refinance costs | $3,280,000 | $4,471,000 | $225,000 | $1,528,000 |
Renovation budgets | $1,827,000 | $2,612,000 | $250,000 | $904,000 |
Asset management fees | $1,537,000 | $2,197,000 | $2,248,000 | $2,751,000 |
Interest paid | $7,444,000 | $10,642,000 | $2,847,000 | $14,892,000 |
Income tax on sales | $2,759,000 | $0 | $0 | $0 |
Income tax on rental income | $0 | $822,000 | $2,315,000 | $90,000 |
Property value at year 30 | $13,154,000 | $23,409,000 | $13,297,000 | $34,336,000 |
Loan balance at year 30 | $4,730,000 | $8,417,000 | $0 | $13,288,000 |
Equity at year 30 | $8,424,000 | $14,992,000 | $13,297,000 | $21,048,000 |
After-tax cash flow received over 30 years | $3,390,000 | $4,024,000 | $4,688,000 | $5,234,000 |
Equity plus cash flow received | $11,814,000 | $19,016,000 | $17,986,000 | $26,282,000 |
Untaxed gain at year 30 | $4,066,000 | $15,466,000 | $12,202,000 | $24,059,000 |
Income tax not yet paid on that gain | $1,189,000 | $4,240,000 | $3,498,000 | $6,941,000 |
Hypothetical illustration. Not a projection of returns.
Owners who sell get fresh depreciation with each purchase and pay little tax on rental income. The Holder that never refinances pays $2.3 million as its depreciation runs out. The refinancing Holder ends with the most untaxed gain, $24.1 million, because it never sold.
Sensitivity to Value Created
Value created per project | Seller | Exchanger | Holder that refinances |
|---|---|---|---|
5% of price | $8,662,000 | $13,553,000 | $23,132,000 |
7.5% | $10,143,000 | $16,091,000 | $24,703,000 |
10% | $11,814,000 | $19,016,000 | $26,282,000 |
12.5% | $13,693,000 | $22,371,000 | $27,947,000 |
15% | $15,798,000 | $26,203,000 | $29,714,000 |
Hypothetical equity plus after-tax cash flow received by year 30; every owner’s projects use the same rate. Not a projection of returns.
With the refinancing Holder’s projects at 10%, the Exchanger’s would each need to create about 15.0% of purchase price to match it, and the Seller’s about 24.6%.
Sources
This article is for educational purposes only and is not an offer to sell, or a solicitation of an offer to buy, any security. Any offering would be made only to eligible investors through formal offering documents. No money or other consideration is being solicited, and if sent, it will not be accepted. Any indication of interest involves no obligation or commitment of any kind.
The example is hypothetical. It does not represent any actual or proposed investment and is not a projection or guarantee of future results. Real estate investments involve risk, including loss of principal. Tax outcomes depend on individual circumstances and on current law, which can change. Figures reflect federal and Pennsylvania law as of October 2026. Consult a qualified tax advisor, estate attorney and securities counsel before making any decision.
General information only. Not investment, legal or tax advice.
Interest list
Interested in future opportunities?
Join the interest list to hear if we launch an offering.